The Sexy Surprise Lighter is a classic gag, where you go to light the lighter and a penis pops up instead of flames. It's funny, but there's a certain trick you've got to use if you're going to make this work.
First, YOU'VE got to light THEIR cigarette. Keep the lighter in your pocket or hand, and when they ask for light, or you see they need one, pull it out.
The reason you have to light their smoke is because the lighter itself doesn't look believable. If you let them feel it or look at, they're going to notice. When you light their cigarette, make sure that your hand is covering up most of it. They aren't going to pay too much attention to it if it's in your hands, so you have that in your favor.
Alright, now that I have taught you the secrets to properly and effectively executing that maneuver, you are ready to laugh your butt off with your friends.
